LooseXboxOne-01
Disc only, no case or manual · Flat sports rate
- Market comp
- $7.79
- Cash (flat)
- $0.50
- Credit (flat)
- $0.75
Xbox One · Trade-In Value
What's MLB The Show 21 Worth? Xbox One Trade-In Value
A CIB copy of MLB The Show 21 comps at $10.00. We pay $1.50 cash or $2.25 store credit. That’s our flat sports rate.
Your offer
MLB The Show 21
Verified in-house photo of this listing
Cash offer · CIB
$1.50
or $2.25 in store creditMarket comp $10.00
Comp last checked October 5, 2026
Every condition
MLB The Show 21 value by condition
3 conditions · same rate on each
CIBXboxOne-02
Complete in box — disc, case, and manual · Flat sports rate
- Market comp
- $10.00
- Cash (flat)
- $1.50
- Credit (flat)
- $2.25
No-PlayXboxOne-03
Disc doesn't play: if it can be resurfaced to play, it pays the same flat sports rate as a working copy. If it can't be resurfaced to a playable state, it's $0.
- Market comp
- $7.79
- Cash (flat)
- $0.50
- Credit (flat)
- $0.75
Xbox One Condition Notes
Cases are standard Blu-ray-style and durable. Unlike prior Xbox consoles' internal power supplies, the Xbox One uses a large external power brick — it's a separate, commonly-missing piece worth confirming is actually included before calling a console listing complete.
We stocked MLB The Show 21 before and it sold. Join the waitlist and we’ll email you when the next one comes through the door.
No guesswork
How we get to your offer
We pull the live market comp for MLB The Show 21 on Xbox One, then apply the same locked rates we use on every trade-in: 55% of comp in cash, or 85% in store credit. No lowball guesswork, no per-item haggling. The comp is the only input, and the math is the same for a common xbox one disc and a grail.
Yearly sports games (Madden, FIFA, NBA 2K, NHL, MLB The Show, NCAA and the like) valued under $15 pay a flat $1.50 complete-in-box ($2.25 credit) or $0.50 loose ($0.75 credit). At $15 and up they pay the normal rates.
Market comp · CIB
$10.00
Flat rate
Sports
Your cash
$1.50
Comp last checked October 5, 2026
Pricing data via PriceCharting
Keep going
Selling more than one?
Xbox One trade-in valueSelling more than one? See what we pay for popular Xbox One games.Xbox One buy listSee what we pay across every Xbox One title on the Buy List.Shop The ShelfBrowse more like this, tested and photographed.
We've traded in a real MLB The Show 21 before. See exactly what we paid.
See the real trade-inPrice guide
More Xbox One Titles
MLB The Show 21 — Common Questions
A Loose MLB The Show 21 comps at $7.79. Cart-A-Vision pays $0.50 cash or $0.75 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
A CIB MLB The Show 21 comps at $10.00. Cart-A-Vision pays $1.50 cash or $2.25 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
Yes. We buy every Xbox One title with a comp on file, MLB The Show 21 included. A CIB copy currently pays $1.50 cash or $2.25 store credit.
It comes down to one question: can it be resurfaced to play? If it can, we pay $0.50 cash or $0.75 store credit for a loose copy (our resurfacing rate). If it can't be resurfaced to a playable state, it's $0 — we don't pay for discs that won't play.
Get restock alerts
We bring in verified Xbox One pieces every other week, not just this one. Get the list before it goes live.
+ 10% off your first order when you join
Have a MLB The Show 21?
Lock in $1.50 cash or $2.25 in store credit for a CIB copy.