Cash Offer
$3,145.00
Ungraded · or $3,145.00 store credit
Reference only — no in-house photo on file yet
Pokémon · Card Value
What's Shining Magikarp (Neo Revelation) Worth? Pokémon Card Value
Neo Revelation · ##66 · 1st Edition Double Holo Error
Shining Magikarp (Neo Revelation) in Ungraded comps at $3,700.00. We pay $3,145.00 cash or $3,145.00 store credit. That’s 85% and 85% of comp, every time.
High-Value Item
This item comps high enough that we double-check it in hand before locking in your offer. Here's today's market-based estimate:
Shining Magikarp value by grade
5 gradesRaw card, near-mint equivalent
- Market Comp
- $3,700.00
- Cash (85%)
- $3,145.00
- Credit (85%)
- $3,145.00
PSA / BGS / CGC 7
- Market Comp
- $5,750.00
- Cash (85%)
- $4,887.50
- Credit (85%)
- $4,887.50
PSA / BGS / CGC 8
- Market Comp
- $7,855.20
- Cash (85%)
- $6,676.92
- Credit (85%)
- $6,676.92
PSA / BGS / CGC 9
- Market Comp
- $9,850.00
- Cash (85%)
- $8,372.50
- Credit (85%)
- $8,372.50
BGS 9.5
- Market Comp
- $10,835.00
- Cash (85%)
- $9,209.75
- Credit (85%)
- $9,209.75
Shining Magikarp condition breakdown
Applying our locked condition multipliers to this card’s own Ungraded comp — the same standard every trade-in prices off.
| Condition | Cash | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Near MintNo visible wear. | $3,145.00 | $3,145.00 |
| Lightly PlayedVery minor edge or surface wear, still displays clean. | $2,673.25 | $2,673.25 |
| Moderately PlayedClearly visible scratches or whitening. | $2,201.50 | $2,201.50 |
| Heavily PlayedSignificant wear, but still intact. | $1,572.50 | $1,572.50 |
| DamagedStructural damage: creases, tears, water damage. | Priced in hand | Priced in hand |
Authentication Notes
Every Pokémon card is checked against known-genuine references: card stock and light-blocking layer, holo foil texture and pattern for that specific era, font and color accuracy on HP/energy symbols, and card-back print quality. First edition WOTC holos and modern alt-art chase cards get extra magnifier-level scrutiny before pricing.
Browse more like this in The Sleeve.
Pricing data via PriceCharting
More from Neo Revelation
Shining Magikarp — Common Questions
A Ungraded Shining Magikarp comps at $3,700.00. Cart-A-Vision pays $3,145.00 cash or $3,145.00 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
A Grade 7 Shining Magikarp comps at $5,750.00. Cart-A-Vision pays $4,887.50 cash or $4,887.50 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
Yes. We buy every Pokémon title with a comp on file, Shining Magikarp included. A Ungraded copy currently pays $3,145.00 cash or $3,145.00 store credit.
How we get to your offer
We pull the live market comp for Shining Magikarp on Pokémon, then apply the same locked rates we use on every trade-in: 85% of comp in cash, or 85% in store credit. No lowball guesswork, no per-item haggling. The comp is the only input, and the math is the same for a common card and a grail.
Comp last checked September 5, 2026