What's Super Mario Bros [5 Screw] Worth? NES Trade-In Value

A CIB copy of Super Mario Bros [5 Screw] comps at $250.00. We pay $212.50 cash or $225.00 store credit. That’s 85% and 90% of comp, every time.

Trade In This NES Cart →

Super Mario Bros [5 Screw] value by condition

4 conditions

LooseCAT. #NES-01

Cartridge only, no box or manual

Market Comp: $19.99
Cash (85%): $16.99
Credit (90%): $17.99

CIBCAT. #NES-02

Complete in box — cart, box, and manual

Market Comp: $250.00
Cash (85%): $212.50
Credit (90%): $225.00

NewCAT. #NES-03

Factory sealed

Market Comp: $418.00
Cash (85%): $355.30
Credit (90%): $376.20

As-IsCAT. #NES-04

Non-functional / As-Is — doesn't power on, priced at 25% of the Loose comp before the standard cash/credit split

Market Comp: $5.00
Cash (85%): $4.25
Credit (90%): $4.50

NES Condition Notes

Loose NES carts often show yellowed or sun-faded end labels, and pin-connector corrosion is common on carts that sat in damp storage — worth a contact clean and a boot test before assuming a cart's dead. CIB copies most commonly show corner-wear or crushing on the box's bottom corners, the weakest point in NES box construction.

In Stock Now

We have a verified Super Mario Bros [5 Screw] ready to ship.

View Listing →

Browse more like this in The Shelf.

See what we pay across every NES title on the Buy List.

NES Buy List →

Pricing data via PriceCharting

More NES Titles

NES

Metroid [5 Screw]

$212.49

NES

Metroid

$162.43

NES

Tennis

$96.48

Bubble Bobble

$85.00

How we get to your offer

We pull the live market comp for Super Mario Bros [5 Screw] on NES, then apply the same locked rates we use on every trade-in: 85% of comp in cash, or 90% in store credit. No lowball guesswork, no per-item haggling. The comp is the only input, and the math is the same for a common nes cart and a grail.

Comp last checked August 30, 2026

Get My $212.50 Offer →How We Grade It