What's Super Mario 64 Worth? Nintendo 64 Trade-In Value

A CIB copy of Super Mario 64 comps at $136.82. We pay $102.62 cash or $116.30 store credit. That’s 65% and 85% of comp, every time.

Trade In This Nintendo 64 Cart →

Super Mario 64 value by condition

4 conditions

LooseCAT. #N64-01

Cartridge only, no box or manual

Market Comp: $33.69
Cash (65%): $21.90
Credit (85%): $28.64

CIBCAT. #N64-02

Complete in box — cart, box, and manual

Market Comp: $136.82
Cash (65%): $102.62
Credit (85%): $116.30

NewCAT. #N64-03

Factory sealed

Market Comp: $567.50
Cash (65%): $425.63
Credit (85%): $482.38

As-IsCAT. #N64-04

Non-functional / As-Is — doesn't power on, priced at 25% of the Loose comp before the standard cash/credit split

Market Comp: $8.42
Cash (65%): $5.47
Credit (85%): $7.16

Nintendo 64 Condition Notes

N64 CIB boxes are notoriously fragile — thinner cardboard than SNES means box crush at the corners and water damage/warping are the two most common condition issues you'll run into. The cartridges themselves hold up well by comparison; label fading is uncommon on this platform.

Browse more like this in The Case.

Pricing data via PriceCharting

More Nintendo 64 Titles

Nintendo 64

Mario Kart 64

$102.48

Nintendo 64

Zelda Ocarina of Time

$120.85

How we get to your offer

We pull the live market comp for Super Mario 64 on Nintendo 64, then apply the same locked rates we use on every trade-in: 65% of comp in cash, or 85% in store credit. No lowball guesswork, no per-item haggling. The comp is the only input, and the math is the same for a common nintendo 64 cart and a grail.

Comp last checked July 30, 2026

Get My $102.62 Offer →How We Grade It