Cash Offer
$127.50
CIB · or $150.00 store credit
Reference only — no in-house photo on file yet
Nintendo 64 · Trade-In Value
What's Super Mario 64 Worth? Nintendo 64 Trade-In Value
A CIB copy of Super Mario 64 comps at $150.00. We pay $127.50 cash or $150.00 store credit. That’s 85% and 100% of comp, every time.
Super Mario 64 value by condition
4 conditionsCartridge only, no box or manual
- Market Comp
- $38.37
- Cash (85%)
- $32.61
- Credit (100%)
- $38.37
Complete in box — cart, box, and manual
- Market Comp
- $150.00
- Cash (85%)
- $127.50
- Credit (100%)
- $150.00
Factory sealed
- Market Comp
- $1,623.90
- Cash (85%)
- $1,380.32
- Credit (100%)
- $1,623.90
Non-functional / As-Is — doesn't power on, priced at 25% of the Loose comp before the standard cash/credit split
- Market Comp
- $9.59
- Cash (85%)
- $8.15
- Credit (100%)
- $9.59
Nintendo 64 Condition Notes
N64 CIB boxes are notoriously fragile — thinner cardboard than SNES means box crush at the corners and water damage/warping are the two most common condition issues you'll run into. The cartridges themselves hold up well by comparison; label fading is uncommon on this platform.
Browse more like this in The Shelf.
See what we pay across every Nintendo 64 title on the Buy List.
Nintendo 64 Buy List →Get Restock Alerts
We bring in verified Nintendo 64 pieces every other week, not just this one. Get the list before it goes live.
Pricing data via PriceCharting
More Nintendo 64 Titles
Super Mario 64 — Common Questions
A Loose Super Mario 64 comps at $38.37. Cart-A-Vision pays $32.61 cash or $38.37 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
A CIB Super Mario 64 comps at $150.00. Cart-A-Vision pays $127.50 cash or $150.00 store credit for one in that condition — the same rate we pay on every trade-in, no per-item haggling.
Yes. We buy every Nintendo 64 title with a comp on file, Super Mario 64 included. A CIB copy currently pays $127.50 cash or $150.00 store credit.
We still buy it, priced as-is at $9.59 comp — $8.15 cash or $9.59 store credit. As-is items are priced off the standard condition's comp, not rejected outright.
How we get to your offer
We pull the live market comp for Super Mario 64 on Nintendo 64, then apply the same locked rates we use on every trade-in: 85% of comp in cash, or 100% in store credit. No lowball guesswork, no per-item haggling. The comp is the only input, and the math is the same for a common nintendo 64 cart and a grail.
Comp last checked September 17, 2026