55–85% CASH ON GAMES✦Locked formula — no lowballs, no negotiating✦Or 85–100% in store credit — your call✦Collectors buying from collectors✦

55–85% CASH ON GAMES✦Locked formula — no lowballs, no negotiating✦Or 85–100% in store credit — your call✦Collectors buying from collectors✦

×

Shop Sell Here What We Pay Buy List What's It Worth Grading

Shop Sell Here What We Pay Buy List What's It Worth Grading

Home/Value Guide/Magic: The Gathering

Card Value

Magic: The Gathering Trade-In Values

1 Magic: The Gathering title priced against a real, live market comp.

← Change machine

Magic: The Gathering

Black Lotus

Alpha

$41,649.54 cash

↑↑↓↓←→←→BA

Midnight Restock

Verified inventory drops every other week. Get the list before it goes live.

Email address

Cart-A-Vision

Buy, sell, and trade retro cartridges and TCG cards. Authenticated, graded, published rate. No repro labels, no mystery board swaps, no inflated card grades.

The Policy, In Numbers

Cash offer — 55% of comp (85% on high-value games, 75% for TCG singles $10+ comp, 85% for TCG singles $200+ comp)
Store credit — 85% of comp (100% on games $30+ comp, 85% for TCG singles $10+ comp)

Same comp, same math, every time. No haggling, no manual overrides. Consoles are a flat 55% cash / 85% credit — not eligible for the high-value bump.

Get In Touch

Contact Us
trades@cart-a-vision.com
(309) 428-1807
Rock Island, IL
Shop All
The Shelf
The Case
The Rack
The Binder
The Sleeve
Start a Trade-In
See what your collection is worth
Sell Games for Cash
Sell TCG Cards for Cash
What We Pay vs. Other Shops
Cart-A-Vision vs DKOldies
Cart-A-Vision vs CATRP
Cart-A-Vision vs MyQuickFlips
Cart-A-Vision vs GameStop
How It Works
How We Grade It
Condition Rates
FAQ
Blog
Check Store Credit
Check Trade-In Status
Privacy Policy
Returns & Refunds
Terms of Service

© 2026 Cart-A-VisionEst. by people who actually love & know the games they’re looking at

Cookie Settings

We use cookies to understand site traffic and improve your experience. You’re in control — accept all, or just the essentials. See our Privacy Policy for details.